Has Kohl's (KSS) Stock Been Good for Investors?
Kohl’s has seen its stock price jump by 64% this year, reversing some of its long-term struggles. Yet the retailer still faces major challenges, from weak financial health to fierce competition. Over the past five years, its shares have fallen by 42%, sharply underperforming the S&P 500’s 83% gain.
The company’s recent positive net income came from a one-time tax adjustment rather than stronger operations. Sales continue to decline, with full-year net sales projected to drop by 3.5% to 4% and comparable sales by 2.5% to 3%. High interest costs—including $75 million in the third quarter alone—add further pressure to its finances.
Kohl’s balance sheet remains weak, holding a quick ratio of just 0.12, indicating low cash reserves and heavy liabilities. Earlier this year, the retailer slashed its dividend by 75%, leaving a modest 2.18% yield. Tight profit margins also restrict any future dividend growth.
Competition has intensified as rivals like Walmart, Costco, and Target expand their product ranges and digital offerings. Among department store peers, Macy’s and Dillard’s have outperformed Kohl’s in same-store sales and margin recovery. Nordstrom’s focus on luxury and omnichannel strategies has yielded mixed results, while J.C. Penney—still recovering from its 2020 bankruptcy—has yet to regain lost ground. Target, though positioned as a mass retailer, has grown faster through private labels and digital investments.
Despite recent stock gains and early signs of a turnaround, Kohl’s fundamentals remain fragile. Declining sales, high debt costs, and strong competition suggest ongoing risks. The company’s long-term performance will depend on whether its strategic initiatives can close the gap with more resilient rivals.