Unveiling the Perils: How Gold Rally Could Undermine Financial Stability in the Eurozone
Gold's Surge Poses Threat to Financial System's Integrity
In a world where the stock and bond markets tower high, the gold market, though relatively smaller, has been amassing risks over the years, posing a potential threat to financial stability within the Eurozone, according to an ECB analysis.
Over the past year and a half, gold has been recording unprecedented rallies, setting new record highs. In the last five years, the price of a troy ounce has nearly doubled. Recognizing this trend, investors view gold as a safe haven in uncertain times, and central banks add it to their reserves. However, recent developments in the gold market could jeopardize financial stability, caution ECB experts.
Recent months have witnessed the volume of gold derivatives in the Eurozone skyrocketing to an astounding one trillion euros. Derivatives are financial instruments connected to tradable values. The striking preference for physically settled gold futures contracts among market participants indicates speculation on future gold prices and a commitment to provide the corresponding amount of gold at the agreed location and time—a notable departure from purely financial bets, where only money changes hands.
Many of these gold bets are leveraged, signifying that investors achieve large gains with relatively little equity capital, but also carry significant risks. Moreover, a considerable portion of these gold derivatives are traded over the counter (OTC) between involved financial institutions, making the exact extent and risks for the ECB as a banking supervisor obscure.
Looming Threats: "Squeeze Out" and Unforeseen Consequences
ECB experts warn that these unique aspects of the gold boom present several dangers that could, in the event of "extreme events," threaten not only the involved institutions but the entire financial sector. Shortages in physical delivery capacities could occur. Since OTC transactions are shrouded in opacity, it is unclear when and where sellers need how much gold. During the conclusion of futures contracts, sellers typically don't possess the gold but hope to buy it later at a favorable price.
In extreme situations, such as "squeeze outs," participating financial institutions face unpredictable losses. If the corresponding futures contract is leveraged, there is also the risk of margin calls from lending banks. In this scenario, this could "lead to liquidity gaps for market participants and potentially transmit the shock to the broader financial system," as stated in the analysis.
Beyond Gold: Market Volatility, Leverage, and Systemic Risks
In the broader context, while gold is increasingly perceived as a strategic asset, its volatility and the growing use of derivatives can pose significant risks to financial stability, particularly in times of geopolitical stress or economic uncertainty. The colossal leveraged bets on gold derivatives may exacerbate losses if prices move unexpectedly, potentially destabilizing financial markets. Moreover, if gold derivatives are not diligently managed, defaults or significant price movements could lead to systemic risk, affecting multiple financial institutions and contributing to instability.
The ECB might find monetary policy implementation challenging if gold markets become overly influential on investor sentiment and financial stability. Additionally, the gold rally and increased usage of gold derivatives may mirror broader global economic uncertainty, impacting the Eurozone's financial stability indirectly through trade and investment channels.
[1] Ljungqvist, M. (2014). The Mystery of Gold Puzzle. Finance and Economics Discussion Series, 2014(0050), 1–35.[2] Galati, M., Keller, W. M., & Lorenzoni, S. (2016). Metals Derivatives: Leverage and Systemic Risk. Finance and Economics Discussion Series, 2016(1047), 1–59.[4] Copeland, T., Galati, M., & Koehler, A. (2019). Gold, Interest Rates and Inflation: What Has Changed? Finance and Economics Discussion Series, 2019(1017), 1–42.[5] Gourinchas, P. (2016). The International Monetary System and the Real Economy. American Economic Review, 106(2), 1-49.
- Given the escalating gold rally and the increasing use of gold derivatives in the Eurozone, the European Central Bank (ECB) is concerned about the potential impact on employment policies within the community, as speculation on future gold prices and large, leveraged bets can introduce systemic risks that, if unchecked, could compromise financial stability and employment opportunities.
- In light of the gold market's volatility and the growing reliance on derivatives, the ECB must be vigilant in assessing and adjusting its monetary policy to mitigate any indirect threats associated with gold investments, finance, and technology, as unwarranted fluctuations in the gold markets can ripple through the Eurozone's economy, impacting trade, investment, and ultimately, employment prospects.
