Comparing Direct vs Traditional Mutual Funds: Which Performs Superior?
In the world of investments, mutual funds offer a popular choice for many individuals. But when it comes to regular and direct mutual fund plans, understanding the key differences can make a significant impact on your returns.
The cost structure, Net Asset Value (NAV), returns, and the role of financial advisors all play a crucial part in distinguishing these two types of plans.
Cost Structure
Direct plans, which allow investors to buy units directly from the Asset Management Company (AMC) or through registered investment advisors, have a lower expense ratio because they exclude distributor and advisor commissions. On the other hand, regular plans include these commissions and marketing costs in the Total Expense Ratio (TER), making them more expensive overall.
Net Asset Value (NAV)
Since regular plans absorb intermediaries’ commissions within their expenses, the NAV of regular plans tends to be lower compared to direct plans for the same mutual fund scheme. Direct plans, having lower fees, generally show a slightly higher NAV reflecting less expenses deducted.
Returns
Direct plans generally deliver higher long-term returns, often potentially 0.5% to 1% more annually, because lower fees compound over time preserving more of the investor’s capital. Regular plans may provide somewhat lower returns because fees and commissions reduce the effective investment growth.
Role of Financial Advisors
Regular plans involve intermediaries such as brokers, distributors, or financial advisors who provide services including product explanation, paperwork assistance, asset-allocation guidance, behavioural coaching, and portfolio management support. This is valuable especially for beginners or investors who prefer guided advisory support. Direct plans, however, require investors to be self-directed, managing their own research, portfolio review, and transactions. They are more suitable for knowledgeable investors or those who pay separately for independent advisory services.
In summary, direct plans cost less and yield somewhat higher NAV and returns but require a do-it-yourself approach, while regular plans cost more due to embedded commissions but offer handholding and advisory support to investors through intermediaries.
Platforms like our platform offer investing in mutual fund direct schemes at zero brokerage and zero commission, making it an attractive choice for cost-conscious investors.
When choosing between regular and direct mutual funds, it's essential to consider your investment objectives, risk appetite, and the level of involvement you are willing to take in managing your investments.
[1] Investopedia. (2021). Direct Mutual Funds vs Regular Mutual Funds. [online] Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/direct_mutual_fund.asp
[2] Investopedia. (2021). Net Asset Value (NAV). [online] Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/netassetvalue.asp
[3] Value Research. (2021). Direct vs Regular Funds: What's the Difference? [online] Available at: https://www.valueresearchonline.com/articles/direct-vs-regular-funds-whats-the-difference/2017/05/22
[4] Moneycontrol. (2021). Direct Mutual Funds vs Regular Mutual Funds: Key Differences Explained. [online] Available at: https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/direct-mutual-funds-vs-regular-mutual-funds-key-differences-explained-7535291.html
[5] BankBazaar. (2021). Direct Mutual Funds vs Regular Mutual Funds: Which One to Choose? [online] Available at: https://www.bankbazaar.com/mutual-funds/direct-vs-regular-mutual-funds-which-one-to-choose-6121.asp
Direct funds and mutual funds are both investment options in the realm of personal-finance and finance, but they differ significantly in terms of cost structure, Net Asset Value (NAV), returns, and the role of financial advisors. Direct funds, being self-managed investments, have a lower cost structure due to the absence of distributor and advisor commissions, resulting in a higher Net Asset Value (NAV) and potentially higher returns compared to mutual funds. On the other hand, mutual funds include these commissions and marketing costs, making them more expensive and often delivering somewhat lower returns. The choice between direct funds and mutual funds should be based on individual investment objectives, risk appetite, and the level of involvement one is willing to take in managing personal investments.
